Most Commented Articles
87 comments in the past 7 days
30 comments in the past 7 days
24 comments in the past 7 days
21 comments in the past 7 days
20 comments in the past 7 days
Core Team
Publisher & Editor-In-Chief
Executive Producer
Executive Producer
Managing Editor
Community Director
Development Director
Staff
Senior Editor, PvP
Senior Editor, PvE
Senior Editor, Lore
Senior Research Manager
Community Manager
Assoc. Community Manager
Assoc. Community Manager
Tag Cloud
 
Feature
9/1/09 1:20 AM -
Comments: Newer to Oldest or Oldest to Newest? 
by sado
, posted September 1st, 2009 at 1:20 AM
One of the aspects of the website that has received some complaints has been our stance on using the newest to oldest comment system instead of the other way around to try to promote discussion on the most recent comments. A few people have expressed that they do not like the newest to oldest system and would rather see a oldest to newest (from top down). Due to this we have decided on reaching out to the community to see what you would like to see on this point in the form of a poll. Let us know why you chose the option as well in the comments section of this post.

[poll id="13"]
 
 
This article's tags:
6 Comments
DH Team
Comment by sado made on 9/3/09 5:14:21 AM
Since this has been such a controversial subject on the site we are coding in an option for the users of the site to be able to define which way they want it.
Comment by RogueJedi86 made on 9/1/09 2:46:59 PM
Hm, I wonder if it's possible to make Comments Order an option for each user to change in their user profile? If that was available, it'd be a nice compromise. "Newest to Oldest", but changeable in your profile.
DH Team
Comment by sado made on 9/3/09 12:27:05 PM
That is exactly what we are doing.
Comment by RogueJedi86 made on 9/1/09 2:17:04 PM
I am in favor of "Oldest to Newest". The other way is just confusing. You start at the very top and work your way down reading the post, then when you hit comments, you gotta go to the very bottom and work your way up, if you're still into reading "Oldest to Newest" like most everything else on the internet does. Just seems contradictory, reading the blog posts up to down(the order the words were written), then having to read the comments down to up to see them in similar chronological order.

And yes, I like oldest first, so I don't neglect the older posts. I read all the comments anyways, so the newer posts aren't being neglected at all. It's just confusing to see opposite order of comments.
DH Team
Comment by Zoidberg made on 9/1/09 2:25:20 PM
I would have hit reply, but this makes RogueJedi's point better. I agree with him and I prefer the Oldest to Newest as well.
DH Team
Comment by Zoidberg made on 9/1/09 2:25:50 PM
Crud, never mind about the first part of the comment.